Welcome back to Tidd Talk! It has been some time since I have posted anything on here and I apologize. The summer came at me fast and before I knew it I was back in school in my busiest semester yet. Anyways, I have been bored lately and I have not had the time to really keep up with the NHL in depth, but I will look to dive back into that in the new year. Today, however, I want to discuss John Cena and his retirement tour.
Many of you may not know, but I am actually a huge WWE fan. This year was a big year as a wrestling fan, as the Never Seen 17 and Greatest Of All Time, John Cena wrestled his final match and gave us a beautiful final chapter in his legendary career. Growing up, I was not the biggest John Cena fan. This in many reasons was because it was cool to root against him. After all, he had the same five moves and rarely put anyone over. He was shoved in our faces and rarely ever changed. But as I have gotten older, and especially over this last year, John Cena has become one of my favorite superstars of all time. I feel this post serves as an homage to a superstar who made up not only my childhood, but my friends’ childhoods as well. Here are my highs and lows from his most recent retirement tour.
Low: John Cena and Logan Paul vs. Cody Rhodes and Jey Uso (Money in the Bank 6/7/25)
This was when we could tell that there was really no plan whatsoever for the heel turn. I get the premise of it, pairing one of your top heels and a heel champion against one of your top faces and your face champion is a good idea in theory, but not on John Cena’s retirement tour, and not when there is no real payoff for Logan Paul. It was a waste of a PLE match for Cena, and could have been done on a Smackdown. The match itself was not awful, but it just did not make any sense. This should have been a title defense for John Cena. They could have done Randy Orton vs. Cena here instead of at the previous Saturday Night’s Main Event. The only bright spot of this match to me was the return of R-Truth/Ron Killings after being released just a week prior. However, once again, there was no payoff for Truth’s return, as Cena’s face turn killed Truth’s momentum and led to Truth being part-time again. Logan went on to tag with Drew McIntyre at Summerslam against Jelly Roll 2 months after he was paired with Cena. Paul should have been pushed as a singles competitor after this match, as that is how they built it up to be, with Paul holding the World Heavyweight title on a SmackDown before. Paul’s feud with Jey should have intensified before having Uso lose to Gunther or even Paul. This match overall was just a waste.

High: Pipe Bomb 2.0 Promo on CM Punk (Smackdown 6/20/25)
This was by far Cena’s best promo during the entire tour. It was easily the best moment of his heel turn and holds a special place in my heart as the original pipe bomb is what made me fall in love with wrestling and CM Punk. The details of this promo were brilliant. From the match against R-Truth to the role reversal with Punk laying through the table just like Cena during the original. This was a full-circle moment for me, and while I was not watching live during the moment, a good friend of mine texted me about it while I was out at a bar. I remember finding the video and pressing the phone up to my ear to listen to what he had to say. I was in awe of the promo. The shoutouts of former WWE guys in other companies with Claudio Castagnoli (Cesaro), Nic Nemeth (Dolph Ziggler), and Matt Cardona (Zack Ryder) were unheard of over the last 20 years of wrestling. Once you left the company, you were rarely mentioned again, and if you were, it certainly was not by your name in another company. The callbacks were just brilliant, and I cannot express it enough. I will include the link in case you have not seen it.
Low: John Cena vs. Brock Lesnar (Wrestlepalooza 9/20/25)
This match was such a bummer. This was the first PLE in the ESPN era, and it was built up to be such a big show, but overall, it disappointed. Cena and Lesnar opened the show, and it was not at all what anyone anticipated. It was a squash. They let Cean do his iconic moves and comebacks, then had Brock finish him. It once again felt like a waste of a PLE match towards the end of the tour, and I will admit, I had lost hope for the rest of the tour afterwards. They could have easily given us a 50/50 match with Lesnar winning, I mean, it is John Cena for crying out loud. There is no reason why Brock was so dominant other than to make him look strong to put a young superstar (Oba Femi?) over in the future. That was the reasoning Cena gave in an interview months after the fact, which makes sense, but still. In my opinion, it was the worst match of the tour and should have been booked way better than it was. It threw a wrench in Lesnar’s return, too, as it was hardly built after his Summerslam return, and they waited till a month and a half after to capitalize. Also, it should have main-evented the card. Cena should have main-evented every card he was on this year, but I digress.

High: Grand Slam Champion in Boston
I am so glad they decided to give Cena the Intercontinental Title in his last run. This was the main thing that I wanted to see, as it just did not seem right to have Cena go out without becoming a Grand Slam Champion. It was also awesome to see it done in Boston. I recall this night thoroughly as I had just finished a stats exam and had gotten a text from my friends to come hang out. I went over to my buddy’s place and told him we had to watch the beginning of Raw. Sure enough, Cena and Dom Mysterio opened the show in Cena’s hometown with an Intercontinental title match. The moment meant so much more than the match to me, but the match was also significant, as it was a chance to see one of my childhood heroes face another one of my childhood heroes’ (Rey Mysterio) son. It was a full circle moment, and you could tell Cena enjoyed working with Dom in not only this match but their match at Survivor Series, too. Dom was the perfect man for Cena to beat for the IC title, and I am glad it happened the way it did. The no sell of the 619 and frog splash by Cena was classic super Cena and it made me really happy to see in 2025.

Low: John Cena vs. CM Punk (Night of Champions 6/28/25)
If you know me, you are likely questioning how the final match between my two favorite wrestlers of all time could possibly be a low. The build was great, and the history was there, but the ending of the match really tainted it for me. This should have ended clean, and I still to this day do not understand the interference. Maybe it was to protect Punk and not make him look weak? I don’t know. What I do know is that Penta served no role in his run-in, and it all seemed sloppy the way it ended. This match bummed me out so much that I held out hope that Cena’s last match at Madison Square Garden would be against Punk for the World Heavyweight title just so I could see this rivalry end properly. That, of course, did not happen. The match itself was actually really entertaining, and the build made it so much better, but the ending was really dumb, which is why it ranks as a low for me.

High: John Cena vs. AJ Styles (Crown Jewel 10/11/25)
This match was wrestling in its purest form. It was the GOAT of WWE vs. the GOAT of TNA. The nostalgia was there, Styles wore a ring gear inspired by what he wore while he was in TNA, and the building was plastered in yellow for Cena, but everyone was there for the match. Nobody was against Styles, as everyone knew this would not disappoint, and there was no heel in the matchup. The match began with a special introduction for Styles, acknowledging his greatness and importance to wrestling, and then it gave us one of the most beautiful matches I have ever seen. So many nods were made by both to legendary superstars such as the Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, Randy Orton, Bray Wyatt, and Chris Jericho. Even the Miz and Rusev had their spot in the match. To see the fireflies come out after Cena hit Styles with the Sister Abigail was something else. Cena got emotional, and you could tell how much it meant to him. This was when we really started to see Cena realize that he was coming towards the end of his career. To me is where he and I began to savor every moment left in the ring. This is when it started to feel real and ultimately revived the tour after the Lesnar squash, and made me happy to see Cena happy.

Low: John Cena vs. Cody Rhodes (Wrestlemania 41 4/20/25)
This was the exact opposite of what the Summerslam bout was. I think we all know that there was supposed to be more to this match in terms of Cena’s heel turn, but something happened with the Rock, and I think they wanted to execute their original plan, whatever that may have been, which is why they had the whole Travis Scott run-in. They definitely could have pivoted to something better had they known everything else was going to fall through, but instead, they went with what they had, and what they had was ultimately disappointing. To cap off the weekend with such a lackluster match after the ending of night 1 really set my expectations low for the rest of the tour. I was happy Cena won his 17th World title, but I was really upset the way it was booked. Travis Scott should not have been involved without the Rock, and we would have been better off if Cena went with a Doctor of Thuganomics turn instead of the turn we had, but I will save that for a little bit later. This once again felt like WWE trying to capitalize on a moment as opposed to the overall storytelling and quality of the match which I have began to despise in the Triple H era.

High: John Cena vs. Cody Rhodes (Summerslam 8/3/25)
This was the sequel to the Wrestlemania 41 match and it did not disappoint. It was a street fight for the Undisputed WWE title that ran 37 minutes and had everything but Cena winning. Cody and Cena put on a hell of a performance that I will never forget. I’ll never forget when Cena came out of the stage with Cody on his shoulders and the look on his face. The build was so much fun for it too, with Cena trying to dodge the match in the prior weeks and Cody essentially forcing Cena to sign the contract for the match. It was also awesome to see Cena turn face (although quite abruptly) and share a beer with Cody on SmackDown before their match. This was Cena’s only one-on-one match with a stipulation during this retirement tour, and I am so glad it was with Cody, as I think Cody has become the king of stipulation matches in modern-day WWE. He lives and breathes wrestling, and if what I have heard is correct, we will get to see him face McIntyre in a 3 Stages of Hell match on the first SmackDown of the year, which I am quite stoked for. This felt like the climax of the tour to me, as everything after this was just icing on the cake. Brock’s return was legendary, I as well many others had thought we would never see him in WWE again. It capped off what I felt was one of the best Summerslams I have ever watched.

Low: The Heel Run
For my last low, I want to look at the heel run as a whole. The turn was phenomenal. The idea that Cena would align himself with the Rock was brilliant, except they had no further plan set in stone. The promos were ridiculous, and it was not at all the John Cena we should have been given for half of his last run. We should have been given an authentic Cena, not an angry one who wanted to ruin wrestling. I personally liked the idea of a heel turn, but I think we should have gotten the Dr. of Thuganomics gimmick for Cena, as it was the best of both worlds. The John Cena we know and love essentially evolved from the Dr. of Thuganomics, and it would have added so much to the nostalgia feel of things. I think the turn wanted to set up for the Rock vs. Cena at some point, with Cena being a face after a possible Cody-Rock alignment, but obviously, this never panned out. The moment was great, but the reality of it is that we were essentially robbed of half of Cena’s retirement tour for views and clicks.

High: John Cena vs. Gunther (Saturday Night’s Main Event 12/13/25)
For many casuals of the business, this is likely the ultimate low. Nobody wanted to see Cena lose in his final match, but it is simply what had to happen. I knew from the beginning that Cena was going to go out on his back, and that is exactly the way he wanted to go. Gunther is the ultimate artist when it comes to professional wrestling, and he was the perfect guy for Cena to lose to in his last match. It was professional wrestling vs. sports entertainment, and unfortunately, it was not sports entertainment’s night, and that’s okay. Cena and Gunther put on a hell of a performance and had me entertained from the start. Cena had me feeling like a kid again, mimicking his “You Can’t See Me” and Five Knuckle Shuffle. The conversation (as Cena likes to call it) that was had with the audience during the endless sleeper hold was one I will forever be grateful for. The night itself was even more beautiful, from legends like Kurt Angle and Rob Van Dam being in attendance to the many promos shown throughout the pre-show and actual show. It was very emotional. The ending was poetic. It was not John Cena giving up; it was him letting go. He held on in a submission that has taken out many greats in the last few years for a long time, and then finally he realized that for others to succeed, one must let go, and he did. It is very Obi-Wan Kenobi-Esque and has set the company and Gunther for great possible success in 2026. The smile on Cena’s face said it all. You could tell he was at peace with his career, and that is all that matters in the end.

Final Thoughts
While the tour was by no means perfect, it certainly had great moments that made up for the bad, and we will never see anything like it again. No superstar in the rest of WWE’s existence will be as influential and great as John Cena was. He is known universally and is likely the only superstar that everyone in the world knows in some fashion. Sure, there are people who found themselves left out of the tour, but that is okay. There were only so many people who could be involved, and I think they nailed the selection. Just like Cena, I am at peace with the way his career went and ended, and I am excited to see what he does next in his acting career. I am thankful for the nostalgia, and I am thankful that I was able to experience this in its entirety over the last year.


























































